Fall Dinner Menu


Lobster Bisque $16.50

Creamy Pumpkin Soup $13


Stilton Almond Stuffed Dates $14.50

Wrapped in Bacon, Served with Potato Croquette and Homemade Jam

Fried Calamari $15

Served with Thai Chili Sauce

Sautéed PEI Mussels $15.50

White Wine with Herb Butter

Artisanal Antipasto Platter for 2 $21

An assortment of Fine Cured Meats and Cheeses

Creamy Burrata $14

Heirloom Tomatoes with a Cabernet Sauvignon Vinaigrette

Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail $18

Served with Cocktail Sauce and Lemon


Crisp Apple Pomegranate Salad $16.50

Fried Goat Cheese, Drizzled Honey, Candied Walnuts, Champagne Vinaigrette

Chef’s Marinated Beet Salad $16.50

Mixed Greens, Goat Cheese Crumble, Passion Fruit Vinaigrette

Gatsby Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $16.50

Grilled Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Creamy Caesar Dressing

 Add Chicken $5            Add Shrimp $6              Add Salmon $8


Pan Seared Atlantic Salmon $28

Dijon Tarragon Sauce over Sautéed Swiss Chard and Roasted Potatoes

French Cut Chicken $26

Stuffed with Brie and Arugula, Over Seasonal Vegetables and Roasted Potatoes

8 oz Center Cut Filet Mignon $39.50

Garlic Mashed Potatoes & Seasonal Vegetables

Butternut Squash Ravioli $19.50

Brown Butter Sauce

Lobster Ravioli $24.50

Creamy Lobster Sauce

Gatsby Steak House Burger $18.50

Applewood Smoked Bacon, Hudson Valley Cheddar, Smokey Red Onion Ketchup

French Fries or Sweet Potato Fries

Italian Sweet Sausage & Penne Pasta $24

With Sautéed Broccoli Rabe and Diced Fresh Tomatoes

Shrimp Stir Fry $22.50

Sesame Glaze Served Over Jasmine Rice

Desserts $9

Decadent Peanut Butter Tower

Brownie Sundae

Juniors Cheesecake

Please let your server know if you have any food allergies prior to ordering. 18% gratuity will be added to parties of 8 or more.


2000 Ocean Parkway, Wantagh, NY 11793

Restaurant Hours

Gatsby restaurant is closed for the season. We are open for private events and catering. For special events and catering inquiries please call 516-287-0577.

Contact us
Phone: (516) 785-0012